Hi everybody,
I would like to clarify matters for the BERG group regarding the lecture series
and to explain my motivation, particularly as I apparently did a poor job of
doing so in the initial email. Let me first say that I am not trying to change
anybody's mind and people are, of course, free to hold their own views.
Moreover, If anybody still does not wish to attend, I understand completely.
The lecture series is dedicated to the "memory" and not the man and, by
dedication, I do not mean veneration, celebration, or otherwise. The series is
named as it is because Harlow's name is associated with two things. The first is
research on attachment, learning, and primate behavior. The second is the fact
that the controversial nature of his research led to massively increased
awareness regarding ethical and welfare considerations in animal research. As
such, every other year the lectures will given by experts in the ethics of
animal research and/or animal welfare from fields such as philosophy. Moreover, I
would like to stress that the research talks will not include invasive studies.
I understand that Harlow's name and work evokes passion and anger among many
people. However, I had hoped that these lectures would be a constructive way to
move forward, both by highlighting the outstanding research in these topics that
can be done ethically and without harming or interfering with the subjects and
in bringing up ethical issues that need to be considered when studying nonhuman
primates or other animals.
I hope that I have been able to better explain myself. I also would like to ask
for help in two matters. First, any suggestions for a subtitle for the lecture
series that would better explain what they are about would be hugely
appreciated. Second, recommendations for suitable speakers, particularly for the
animal ethics/welfare talks, would be great, too. So far I have gotten some
excellent suggestions for the latter, but more cannot hurt.
Anyway, I am sorry to be so long-winded and appreciate the time you have taken
to read this. If anybody wishes to discuss this with me further, please feel
free to contact me directly.
Sincerely,
Alex
--
The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in
Scotland, with registration number SC005336.
While of course I agree with Liz's opinions regarding Harlow's research, it is a serious
historical error to judge the behaviour of a scientist of 50-odd years ago by the standards of today.
Today, homosexuals may marry and even contrive to have children: 50-odd years ago their behaviour was
punishable by custodial sentence. In both cases, what was done then was acceptable in 'the court
of public opinion' of the time, and is unacceptable in that court today.
One would have to be brave (and foolish) to say that everything which is acceptable today
in animal science will be acceptable in 50-odd years time, or that everything which is now
unacceptable will always be so.
Robin
Robin N Campbell
Psychology, Stirling
r.n.campbell(a)stir.ac.uk
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Dear BERGers,
I was astonished and dismayed to learn that someone in our group would dedicate anything to Harry Harlow, and I will not be attending these lectures.
To quote Robert Sapolsky in Scientific American:
“These [Harlow’s] were brutal studies, animals shattered by isolation. They made Harlow a pariah in many circles. Useful science was produced (though not nearly enough to justify the extent of what was done, in my opinion). Animals suffered unspeakably.
“He [Harlow] did ethically troubling work without seeming ethically troubled. He responded to feminist and animal-rights critiques with caustic hostility, dinosaurish misogyny and flaunted indifference to his animals. His writing was savage and crude: I recall being moved to tears and outrage by those papers as a student. (An example: females who were socially isolated as infants were inept at mating. How to get them pregnant, to study their subsequent maternal behavior? Harlow wrote, proudly, of his 'rape rack.')”
Sincerely,
Liz Williamson
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Christine Caldwell <c.a.caldwell(a)stir.ac.uk<x-msg://5/c.a.caldwell@stir.ac.uk>>
Date: 27 October 2011 08:28
Subject: [BERG] FW: Harry Harlow Lecture
To: berg Mailing List <berg(a)lists.stir.ac.uk<x-msg://5/berg@lists.stir.ac.uk>>
Hi all,
Please see the email below from Alex Weiss about a lecture being held in Edinburgh on Monday.
Christine.
Hi everybody,
As part of the seminar series we have instituted a series of lectures dedicated
to the memory of Harry Harlow. Each seminar in this series will be held on the
Monday closest to his birthday (31 October) every year.
Harry Harlow was most famous for his "mother love" experiments which were
inspired by the work of John Bowlby and others. He found that the need for
'contact comfort' was key to the development of rhesus macaques and likely
humans. His work was not without controversy, but he contributed hugely to
research on attachment, animal behavior, learning, and several other areas
throughout his lifetime. These lectures will explore important themes from this
work, and will also include lectures on the ethics of animal research and animal
welfare.
The seminar will take place at the 7 George Square, The University of Edinburgh
at 5:15 and will be followed by a wine reception. The speaker will be
Bonaventura Majolo of Lincoln University.
The title of the talk is "Managing social relationships in wild macaques" and
should be of interest to those studying evolutionary psychology, social
psychology, and animal behavior.
Abstract: Nonhuman primates seem capable of establishing and maintaining long-
lasting social relationship with their group companions that resemble human
friendships. Recent studies on various primate species indicate that such
friendly relationships can be beneficial to individual fitness: animals having
stronger social bonds with their group companions have higher reproductive
success. Here I will discuss two aspects of social relationships namely, the
role of reciprocity and conflict resolution. Reciprocity is considered a key
feature of high quality social relationships in both humans and other species.
However, the reciprocal exchange of altruistic acts often occurrs at such low
rates so as to undermine its importance for friendship. Moreover, the asymmetric
nature of social relationships is frequently underestimated. With respect to
conflict resolution, I will discuss the importance of relationship quality for
the occurrence of reconciliation and how the post-conflict period may represent
an excellent opportunity to study the behavioural consequences of social
uncertainty.
Should anybody be interested in attending dinner with the speaker, please
contact me as soon as possible.
Best,
Alex
--
The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in
Scotland, with registration number SC005336.
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Dear BERGers
We have Becky Leonardi speaking on Wednesday, describing her PhD programme:
Paws for Progress - A dog training rehabilitation programme
Becky has asked me to emphasise that there are no results as yet, but I know it will be an interesting session so please come along.
5.30pm - 3A94 as usual.
See you then, Hannah
If you wish to subscribe (or unsubscribe) to the BERG mailing list please follow instructions here:
http://lists.stir.ac.uk/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/berg
Hannah M. Buchanan-Smith
Professor, Behaviour and Evolution Research Group
Psychology, School of Natural Sciences
University of Stirling
Stirling, FK9 4LA
Scotland
Tel: 01786 467674
Fax: 01786 467641
E-mail: h.m.buchanan-smith(a)stir.ac.uk<mailto:h.m.buchanan-smith@stir.ac.uk>
http://www.psychology.stir.ac.uk/staff/staff-profiles/academic-staff/hannah…
________________________________
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159.
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Hi folks,
If you have a chance, check out the next episode of *Origins of Us on BBC2
(Monday, 31 October @ 9pm) *which examines evolution of the brain. This
episode includes a segment on social politics highlighting the dynamics
within Edinburgh Zoo's recently formed group of 21 chimpanzees as I chat
briefly with Dr Alice Roberts about Machiavellian intelligence.
*Brains*
Episode: 3 of 3
Duration: 1 hour
In the final episode Dr Alice Roberts explores how our species, homo
sapiens, developed our large brain; and asks why we are the only one of our
kind left on the planet today?
The evolution of the human mind is one of the greatest mysteries. We are
special because of our extraordinary brain, and to understand why we think
and act the way we do, we need to look at where and why our brains evolved.
The Rift Valley in Kenya is thought to be the crucible of human evolution,
and here Alice examines the fossils in our family tree which reveal our
brains have more than quadrupled in size since our ancestors split from
chimpanzees. Drawing on research on social politics in chimpanzees, the
cognitive development of children and the tools that have been found
littered across the Rift Valley, Alice explores how and why our ancestors
brains became so big. It's thought their need to understand each other and
share knowledge has fundamentally shaped the brains we live with today.
But our big brains came at a cost. Alice visits a maternity hospital to
explore how our difficulties in giving birth are a result of our large
brained babies, and travels to meet the women of the Hadza tribe to explore
how looking after our large-brained children has shaped the life histories
of all of us. Research suggests old age isn't a consequence of modern
medicine, but an evolutionary adaptation to allow grandmothers to help
raise their grandchildren.
Successive species of increasingly large brained humans migrated around the
world - from Homo erectus to heidelbergensis, the Neanderthals to us. It's
always been assumed the reason that Homo sapiens succeeded where others
failed is to do with our large brains. But comparing skulls it's clear
Neanderthals had just as big a brain as us. So why is there only us left?
Alice goes to meet Svante Paabo, decoding the Neanderthal and human genome,
and Clive Finlayson, who is unearthing the Neanderthals final settlement,
to try to find out...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b013gmh1
Cheers,
Betsy
Elizabeth (Betsy) Herrelko
Postgraduate Student, University of Stirling
Honorary Research Associate, Royal Zoological Society of Scotland
www.chimpcam.com
Hi all,
Please see the email below from Alex Weiss about a lecture being held in Edinburgh on Monday.
Christine.
Hi everybody,
As part of the seminar series we have instituted a series of lectures dedicated
to the memory of Harry Harlow. Each seminar in this series will be held on the
Monday closest to his birthday (31 October) every year.
Harry Harlow was most famous for his "mother love" experiments which were
inspired by the work of John Bowlby and others. He found that the need for
'contact comfort' was key to the development of rhesus macaques and likely
humans. His work was not without controversy, but he contributed hugely to
research on attachment, animal behavior, learning, and several other areas
throughout his lifetime. These lectures will explore important themes from this
work, and will also include lectures on the ethics of animal research and animal
welfare.
The seminar will take place at the 7 George Square, The University of Edinburgh
at 5:15 and will be followed by a wine reception. The speaker will be
Bonaventura Majolo of Lincoln University.
The title of the talk is "Managing social relationships in wild macaques" and
should be of interest to those studying evolutionary psychology, social
psychology, and animal behavior.
Abstract: Nonhuman primates seem capable of establishing and maintaining long-
lasting social relationship with their group companions that resemble human
friendships. Recent studies on various primate species indicate that such
friendly relationships can be beneficial to individual fitness: animals having
stronger social bonds with their group companions have higher reproductive
success. Here I will discuss two aspects of social relationships namely, the
role of reciprocity and conflict resolution. Reciprocity is considered a key
feature of high quality social relationships in both humans and other species.
However, the reciprocal exchange of altruistic acts often occurrs at such low
rates so as to undermine its importance for friendship. Moreover, the asymmetric
nature of social relationships is frequently underestimated. With respect to
conflict resolution, I will discuss the importance of relationship quality for
the occurrence of reconciliation and how the post-conflict period may represent
an excellent opportunity to study the behavioural consequences of social
uncertainty.
Should anybody be interested in attending dinner with the speaker, please
contact me as soon as possible.
Best,
Alex
--
The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in
Scotland, with registration number SC005336.
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Jim sent this on – as he thought this position might interest some graduating students, BERG members etc.
Assistant Teamleader Primate Department
Hiring Organization:
Stichting AAP
Position Description:
At Foundation AAP we give shape to our ideal in a professional manner: to improve the welfare of abused or neglected exotic apes and small to medium-sized mammals from all over Europe. For one thing we do this by providing shelter for animals from the illegal trade, circuses, animal testing laboratories or simply private owners. For most animals we find suitable new homes in reserves, zoos or in our own permanent shelter in the south of Spain.
AAP also works to prevent welfare issues by actively exercising influence through both Dutch and European policy-makers and decision-makers in this area, and working work with domestic and foreign professional parties on an active and strategic level. Furthermore, AAP is an internationally authoritative knowledge centre.
There are about 70 people on our pay roll and we have an equal number of volunteers, established on a spacious and modern location in the middle of the green area near Almere. Nowhere else would you be able to see the result of your efforts so directly: each animal taken to our grounds and into our care, recuperates. You will be part of a tight, professional group of colleagues: from caretaker to fundraiser, all with the same ideal purpose.
Qualifications/Experience:
Your role
In this remarkably versatile and fascinating position you coordinate and execute the animal care process in the Primate Department. You conduct this work under the leadership and responsibility of the team leader of this department. Practically your activities will consist of facilitating your team, in order to optimize daily affairs in the department. Now and then you will be cooperative / executive (tending to, cleaning, feeding, observing and help forming primate groups). The team exist of 10 (partially english speaking) experienced animal care takers, trainees and volunteers. Additionally you will have some administrative tasks.
Salary/funding:
Our offer
We offer a job with much individual responsibility in an open international, professional organisation in a natural environment where animals and humans are what it’s all about. Your initial salary varies between € 1.403 and € 1.552 (gross based on 32 hours), and anual growth is possible.
Support provided for internship/volunteer positions (travel, meals, lodging):
Free lunch
Term of Appointment:
Carrying out a practical assignment is part of the application procedure.
Application Deadline:
7 november 2011
Comments:
You can call Huub Vlemmix, team leader primates, for more info: (036)5238755. Send your application letter and CV before November 7th 2011 mentioning number 2011-18-ORATLPR, preferably by e-mail to working.at(a)aap.nl<mailto:working.at@aap.nl> or by mail to Stichting AAP, Kemphaanpad 1, P.O. Box 50313, 1305 AH Almere, The Netherlands, attn. Elly Koppers, Coordinator Personnel Department.
Contact Information:
Elly Koppers
Kemphaanpad 1
Almere 1305 AH
Netherlands
Telephone Number:
0031 36 5238787
Website:
http://www.aap.nl
E-mail Address:
elly.koppers(a)aap.nl<mailto:elly.koppers@aap.nl>
------ End of Forwarded Message
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Please find attached details of the UFAW animal welfare student scholarship meeting, with many interesting talks.
This is a free meeting, but it is important you let Steve know if you plan to go to it (see message below).
It's a packed week:
On Wednesday we have Dr Jim Anderson with a presentation entitled: Monkeys judge reciprocity between humans
5.30pm - in 3A94, Cottrell Building.
On Thursday we have Dr Susanne Schultz (Oxford University) presenting on: Investigating evolutionary trends in brain size and architecture (4pm, 3A94)
Later on Thursday Prof Andy Whiten (St Andrews University) is talking at Edinburgh Zoo (7.30pm) in the Living Links to Human Health, Mind, and Medicine lecture series
20th October 2011 - "Culturally transmitted information, nutrition and health in the great apes" by Professor Andrew Whiten, University of St Andrews. Professor Whiten is Scientific Director of the Living Links Centre and an international authority on social learning and culture in human and non-human primates. This talk will also give an overview of what the talk series is about.
We have no BERG talks the following week as it is our mid semester break, but note:
27th October 2011 - "Putting our past into the present: the emerging field of evolutionary medicine" by Professor Gillian Bentley, Durham University. Professor Bentley is a leader in this field in the UK. Her theme is that many sources of our illness and health may be better understood using an evolutionary perspective, with the implications this yet to be fully recognised and exploited by modern medicine.
If you are planning to go please let us know at BERG in case a car share is possible. See here for how to get your ticket (£3).
http://rzss.wordpress.com/2011/09/09/living-links-to-human-health-mind-and-…
Hannah
If you wish to subscribe (or unsubscribe) to the BERG mailing list please follow instructions here:
http://lists.stir.ac.uk/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/berg
From: Stephen Wickens [mailto:wickens@ufaw.org.uk]
Sent: 14 October 2011 09:45
Subject: UFAW link and animal welfare student scholarship meeting, 7th December University of Cambridge 2012
Dear UFAW link,
Please find attached the programme for our forthcoming UFAW animal welfare student scholarship meeting, which this year is very kindly being hosted by Dr David Williams at the Department of Veterinary Medicine at Cambridge. I would be grateful if you could make your colleagues and students aware of it.
As usual, this meeting will feature talks from those students who were awarded UFAW animal welfare student scholarships in 2011 and a couple of guest speakers, Dr Louise Buckley (Harper Adams) on broiler breeders and assessing their hunger and Rowena Packer (RVC) on breathing problems in brachycephalic breeds of dog. These meetings are free and open to all who wish to attend, with lunch and refreshments provided. If you or any of your students are thinking of attending however I would be grateful if they could let me know in advance so that I can ensure sufficient catering is laid on.
Hope to see some of you at the meeting.
Thank you for your support of UFAW and the promotion of animal welfare science.
Regards,
Steve
Stephen Wickens, PhD
Development Officer
Universities Federation for Animal Welfare
The Old School, Brewhouse Hill, Wheathampstead, Herts AL4 8AN, UK
Email: wickens(a)ufaw.org.uk<mailto:wickens@ufaw.org.uk>
Direct tel: +(0)1276 500880
Office: +(0)1582 831818 (tel), 831414 (fax)
Registered Charity No 207996 (Registered in England) and Company Limited by Guarantee No 579991
The Universities Federation for Animal Welfare (UFAW) is an independent registered UK charity that works to develop and promote improvements in the welfare of all animals through scientific and educational activity worldwide.
Science in the service of animal welfare
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Dear all
We have Andrew Bagnall, who teaches Higher Biology at St Thomas school in Edinburgh, is coming on Wednesday to give a slide show and tell us about his recent adventures on
A visit to Seram Island, Indonesia
5.30pm - but change of usual venue to room 2A73
Andrew has asked me to emphasise the presentation is lacking in data, but I am confident it will be packed with interest!
See you then, Hannah
If you wish to subscribe (or unsubscribe) to the BERG mailing list please follow instructions here:
http://lists.stir.ac.uk/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/berg
Hannah M. Buchanan-Smith
Professor, Behaviour and Evolution Research Group
Psychology, School of Natural Sciences
University of Stirling
Stirling, FK9 4LA
Scotland
Tel: 01786 467674
Fax: 01786 467641
E-mail: h.m.buchanan-smith(a)stir.ac.uk<mailto:h.m.buchanan-smith@stir.ac.uk>
http://www.psychology.stir.ac.uk/staff/staff-profiles/academic-staff/hannah…
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.
Dear all
I am looking forward to seeing you all on Wednesday at our first BERG meeting -5.30 pm in the Psychology Common Room (3A94, Cottrell Building).
This will be introductions, social catch up and a show of photos by Peter Hancock from his trip to Shetland. We shall also use this opportunity to take new photos of the group for the BERG website!
We shall also make an effort to finalise the programme which is already looking excellent - thanks to all those who have signed up.
We still have slots free (note that Bethan may move her presentation to December due to popular demand), and are looking for volunteers. Remember that you don't need a polished talk - you can offer to lead a discussion on a journal paper, or present research ideas etc.
Date
Person Responsible
Speaker and Topic
21 September
Hannah
Introductions - drinks, nibbles, catch up
Peter Hancock will show photos from Shetland
28th September
Hannah
Roman Wittig (presenting) & Cathy Crockford (University of St Andrews) - Social bonds among chimpanzees - physiological evidence
5 October
2A73
Hannah
Andrew Bagnall (Edinburgh) - A visit to Seram Island, Indonesia
Change of location - 2A73
12 October (HBS away)
19 October
Jim
Jim Anderson - Monkeys judge reciprocity between humans
26 October
MID-SEMESTER
2 November
9 November (HBS away)
Rob
Rob Burriss - Mate-preference versus mate-choice in humans
16 November
Hannah
Emily Messer (St Andrews) - Squirrel monkey social learning
23 November
Louise
Louise Lock - Chimpanzees' preferred nesting materials
30 November
Hannah
Bethan Morgan - Chimpanzee conservation
7 December
14 December
Hope to see you on Wednesday, Hannah
Hannah M. Buchanan-Smith
Professor, Behaviour and Evolution Research Group
Psychology, School of Natural Sciences
University of Stirling
Stirling, FK9 4LA
Scotland
Tel: 01786 467674
Fax: 01786 467641
E-mail: h.m.buchanan-smith(a)stir.ac.uk<mailto:h.m.buchanan-smith@stir.ac.uk>
http://www.psychology.stir.ac.uk/staff/staff-profiles/academic-staff/hannah…
--
The Sunday Times Scottish University of the Year 2009/2010
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland,
number SC 011159.