21 Dec
2023
21 Dec
'23
2:58 p.m.
Dear Behavioural Science Cluster,
I hope I am catching most of you before heading out the door for a well-deserved break!
As you probably know, IAS has announced a new competition round for PhD scholarships for
the coming year.
Gözde and I (as PIs of this year’s bid) have had a post-mortem meeting with Iain to
receive feedback on why our cluster was unsuccessful. One of the key points that held us
back was that our cluster theme was perceived as too broad. We always knew that a
catch-all strategy (cluster theme = Behavioural Science), which set us apart from the
other, much narrower, cluster themes, could go either way. Now we know, which way it went:
the wrong one.
Anyway, what was very clear to us after meeting with Iain is that (if we want to have
another go in 2024), we need to significantly narrow the cluster theme. We asked Iain if
this was possible under the IAS rules that only previously pre-approved clusters were able
to compete next year and he said that it would be.
So, after some pondering, Gözde and I have decided that we’d be willing to throw our hats
in the ring once more - provided we have the support from the cluster.
Together with Iain, we had a look at the competing cluster themes (many of which are
behavioural science in nature already) and the clearest opening (as in: least crowded
field of competing bids) was in Environmental Behaviour. Given the abundance of expertise
in our cluster in Behavioural Health, we are also considering a cluster theme that
combines, Behaviour, Health, and Environment. This would also be a great match for the
University’s new R&I strategy (Spaces, Places & Lives), as we will have to reframe
our initial proposal to this R&I strategy anyway (see details
here<https://stir.sharepoint.com/sites/InstituteforAdvancedStudies/Share…)true&ga=1>).
So here are our questions to you:
(1) Are there any objections to entering the 2024 competition with a theme narrowed to
Environmental Behaviour (and possibly added Behavioural Health)?
* Importantly: The narrowing of our cluster theme would only affect our PhD
studentship bid. The theme of our Behavioural Science cluster as a research group would
remain a broad tent!
* Also: If you have an alternative idea for rebranding our IAS bid (and/or would be
interested in Co-PIing it), we’d be very keen to hear it
(2) Who would want to join such a revised IAS bid?
* Just as last time, we are looking for a healthy mix of senior colleagues and ECRs
(3) Optional (but highly welcome): If you raised your hand under (2), could you give us a
concrete example of a potential research topic or two?
* The less general our proposal, the better our chances
We would be very happy to hear from you regarding these three points.
The deadline to submit our revised bid is Tuesday, 9th of January (thanks IAS... ;-) ). If
we feel that the support from the cluster is there, Gözde and I would be willing to give
it another go.
Best wishes, and happy holidays, once they come!
Gözde and Till
________________________________
Scotland’s University for Sporting Excellence
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159
5 Jan
5 Jan
1:22 p.m.
Dear Behavioural Science Cluster,
Happy New Year!
Since the deadline for the PhD proposal submission is fast approaching, we would like to
send a wee reminder about the below.
In particular, we would like to ask, who would be interested in joining the revised IAS
bid (see details below) as part of the supervisor pool. If that’s you, we would love to
hear from you by coming Monday, 8th of January, at noon.
Thank you!
Gözde and Till
On 21. Dec 2023, at 14:58, Till Stowasser
<till.stowasser@stir.ac.uk<mailto:till.stowasser@stir.ac.uk>> wrote:
Dear Behavioural Science Cluster,
I hope I am catching most of you before heading out the door for a well-deserved break!
As you probably know, IAS has announced a new competition round for PhD scholarships for
the coming year.
Gözde and I (as PIs of this year’s bid) have had a post-mortem meeting with Iain to
receive feedback on why our cluster was unsuccessful. One of the key points that held us
back was that our cluster theme was perceived as too broad. We always knew that a
catch-all strategy (cluster theme = Behavioural Science), which set us apart from the
other, much narrower, cluster themes, could go either way. Now we know, which way it went:
the wrong one.
Anyway, what was very clear to us after meeting with Iain is that (if we want to have
another go in 2024), we need to significantly narrow the cluster theme. We asked Iain if
this was possible under the IAS rules that only previously pre-approved clusters were able
to compete next year and he said that it would be.
So, after some pondering, Gözde and I have decided that we’d be willing to throw our hats
in the ring once more - provided we have the support from the cluster.
Together with Iain, we had a look at the competing cluster themes (many of which are
behavioural science in nature already) and the clearest opening (as in: least crowded
field of competing bids) was in Environmental Behaviour. Given the abundance of expertise
in our cluster in Behavioural Health, we are also considering a cluster theme that
combines, Behaviour, Health, and Environment. This would also be a great match for the
University’s new R&I strategy (Spaces, Places & Lives), as we will have to reframe
our initial proposal to this R&I strategy anyway (see details
here<https://stir.sharepoint.com/sites/InstituteforAdvancedStudies/Share…)true&ga=1>).
So here are our questions to you:
(1) Are there any objections to entering the 2024 competition with a theme narrowed to
Environmental Behaviour (and possibly added Behavioural Health)?
* Importantly: The narrowing of our cluster theme would only affect our PhD
studentship bid. The theme of our Behavioural Science cluster as a research group would
remain a broad tent!
* Also: If you have an alternative idea for rebranding our IAS bid (and/or would be
interested in Co-PIing it), we’d be very keen to hear it
(2) Who would want to join such a revised IAS bid?
* Just as last time, we are looking for a healthy mix of senior colleagues and ECRs
(3) Optional (but highly welcome): If you raised your hand under (2), could you give us a
concrete example of a potential research topic or two?
* The less general our proposal, the better our chances
We would be very happy to hear from you regarding these three points.
The deadline to submit our revised bid is Tuesday, 9th of January (thanks IAS... ;-) ). If
we feel that the support from the cluster is there, Gözde and I would be willing to give
it another go.
Best wishes, and happy holidays, once they come!
Gözde and Till
________________________________
Scotland’s University for Sporting Excellence
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159
--
BehSci mailing list
BehSci@lists.stir.ac.uk<mailto:BehSci@lists.stir.ac.uk>
http://lists.stir.ac.uk/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/behsci
________________________________
Scotland’s University for Sporting Excellence
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159
2:59 p.m.
Hi Till,
Sorry forgot to reply before christmas, you can count on me, thanks for giving it another
go :)
Willem
Dr Willem Sas
Lecturer in Economics
University of Stirling, Economics Division, Stirling, Scotland, FK9 4LA
T: 01786 466412 ¦ E: willem.sas(a)stir.ac.uk ¦ W:
willemsas.com<http://willemsas.com/>
From: BehSci <behsci-bounces(a)lists.stir.ac.uk> On Behalf Of Till Stowasser
Sent: Friday, January 5, 2024 2:22 PM
To: behsci Mailing List <behsci(a)lists.stir.ac.uk>
Subject: Re: [Behsci] IAS studentship competition 2024 – Your opinions are needed
Dear Behavioural Science Cluster,
Happy New Year!
Since the deadline for the PhD proposal submission is fast approaching, we would like to
send a wee reminder about the below.
In particular, we would like to ask, who would be interested in joining the revised IAS
bid (see details below) as part of the supervisor pool. If that’s you, we would love to
hear from you by coming Monday, 8th of January, at noon.
Thank you!
Gözde and Till
On 21. Dec 2023, at 14:58, Till Stowasser
<till.stowasser@stir.ac.uk<mailto:till.stowasser@stir.ac.uk>> wrote:
Dear Behavioural Science Cluster,
I hope I am catching most of you before heading out the door for a well-deserved break!
As you probably know, IAS has announced a new competition round for PhD scholarships for
the coming year.
Gözde and I (as PIs of this year’s bid) have had a post-mortem meeting with Iain to
receive feedback on why our cluster was unsuccessful. One of the key points that held us
back was that our cluster theme was perceived as too broad. We always knew that a
catch-all strategy (cluster theme = Behavioural Science), which set us apart from the
other, much narrower, cluster themes, could go either way. Now we know, which way it went:
the wrong one.
Anyway, what was very clear to us after meeting with Iain is that (if we want to have
another go in 2024), we need to significantly narrow the cluster theme. We asked Iain if
this was possible under the IAS rules that only previously pre-approved clusters were able
to compete next year and he said that it would be.
So, after some pondering, Gözde and I have decided that we’d be willing to throw our hats
in the ring once more - provided we have the support from the cluster.
Together with Iain, we had a look at the competing cluster themes (many of which are
behavioural science in nature already) and the clearest opening (as in: least crowded
field of competing bids) was in Environmental Behaviour. Given the abundance of expertise
in our cluster in Behavioural Health, we are also considering a cluster theme that
combines, Behaviour, Health, and Environment. This would also be a great match for the
University’s new R&I strategy (Spaces, Places & Lives), as we will have to reframe
our initial proposal to this R&I strategy anyway (see details
here<https://stir.sharepoint.com/sites/InstituteforAdvancedStudies/Share…)true&ga=1>).
So here are our questions to you:
(1) Are there any objections to entering the 2024 competition with a theme narrowed to
Environmental Behaviour (and possibly added Behavioural Health)?
* Importantly: The narrowing of our cluster theme would only affect our PhD
studentship bid. The theme of our Behavioural Science cluster as a research group would
remain a broad tent!
* Also: If you have an alternative idea for rebranding our IAS bid (and/or would be
interested in Co-PIing it), we’d be very keen to hear it
(2) Who would want to join such a revised IAS bid?
* Just as last time, we are looking for a healthy mix of senior colleagues and ECRs
(3) Optional (but highly welcome): If you raised your hand under (2), could you give us a
concrete example of a potential research topic or two?
* The less general our proposal, the better our chances
We would be very happy to hear from you regarding these three points.
The deadline to submit our revised bid is Tuesday, 9th of January (thanks IAS... ;-) ). If
we feel that the support from the cluster is there, Gözde and I would be willing to give
it another go.
Best wishes, and happy holidays, once they come!
Gözde and Till
________________________________
Scotland’s University for Sporting Excellence
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159
--
BehSci mailing list
BehSci@lists.stir.ac.uk<mailto:BehSci@lists.stir.ac.uk>
http://lists.stir.ac.uk/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/behsci
________________________________
Scotland’s University for Sporting Excellence
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159
________________________________
Scotland’s University for Sporting Excellence
The University of Stirling is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC 011159
454
days inactive
469
days old
2 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
Till Stowasser -
Willem Sas