[Media-watch] UK troops investigated over deaths of 10 Iraqi civilians - Independent - 30/05/2004

[Julie-ann Davies]

http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/politics/story.jsp?story=526371

UK troops investigated over deaths of 10 civilians
First official recognition of abuse scandal. Minister's report 'slipped out'
before recess
By Severin Carrell and Andy McSmith
30 May 2004


The Government has officially admitted for the first time that the Army is
investigating the deaths of 10 Iraqi civilians from "ill-treatment" at the
hands of British soldiers.

The new figure, slipped out in a written answer as MPs left Westminster for
a two-week break, suggests the level of abuse of civilians by British forces
has been greater than previously thought.

Until now, ministers had admitted to five cases involving allegations that
Iraqi civilians had died after been beaten or mistreated - including the now
notorious case exposed by The Independent on Sunday, of the hotel
receptionist Baha Mousa.

Adam Ingram, the Armed Forces minister, admitted last week that there were
16 cases involving alleged mistreatment of Iraqis under investigation - 10
of which "resulted in the death of a civilian".

Ministry of Defence officials confirmed the cases involve "abuse or
ill-treatment" by British troops, and excluded civilians shot dead, killed
in traffic accidents or deaths in custody by what was judged to be natural
causes.

However, opposition MPs are increasingly critical of the MoD's handling of
these cases after the Government's lawyers ordered ministers not to release
further details. The MoD claims giving out names and causes of death could
prejudice investigations and potential prosecutions.

Adam Price, the Plaid Cymru MP who is pursuing the cases in Parliament, said
this contradicted Mr Ingram's promise to MPs in early May that he wanted to
"release as much further detail as possible on all these incidents".

"It's simply indefensible. They should be trying to dispel any perception
that there is a lack of transparency and accountability. They should be
putting as much information out as possible," he said.

Sir Menzies Campbell, the Liberal Democrat foreign affairs spokesman, said:
"This is the first time the minister for Defence has indicated there were so
many cases going on. It's essential that all these allegations are
investigated rigorously and expeditiously. If it were to emerge that there
has been serious misbehaviour by British forces, then there would be
considerable embarrassment in Whitehall."

Labour MP Peter Kilfoyle, a former defence minister, said: "It's extremely
unfortunate that it's on the last day when this answer is slipped out. It
obviously prevents us from seeking a fuller account of what this answer
refers to."

In addition to Baha Mousa, the previously known cases include Hassan Abbad
(or Abdul) Said on 2 August 2003, which is being investigated by the
Metropolitan Police and the Crown Prosecution Service after the commanding
officer of the unnamed regiment involved said his troops had no case to
answer.

Other cases include that of Abd Al Jubba Mousa, a primary school headmaster
who died last May in Basra after soldiers from the Black Watch allegedly hit
him repeatedly on the head with rifle butts and a helmet as they were
arresting him. Two soldiers were later sent home.

The fourth case involves the death of Ahmad Jabbar Kareem, 17, who drowned
after being allegedly forced to swim a river following a severe beating by
British troops in May last year.

In the fifth case, Ather Karim al-Mowafakia, 24, died after being shot and
allegedly beaten by a British soldier, after he accidentally hit a soldier
with his car door. His body was later exhumed by British investigators.