[Media-watch] National guard soldiers ordered to just "walk away" from torture scene - The Oregonian - 8th and 9th August 2004

[Julie-ann Davies]

http://www.oregonlive.com/search/index.ssf?/base/exclude/1092052701302081.xml?oregonian?ylccmf

Ordered to just walk away
Sunday, August 08, 2004

MIKE FRANCIS

BAGHDAD -- The national guardsman peering through the long-range scope of
his rifle was startled by what he saw unfolding in the walled compound
below.

>From his post several stories above ground level, he watched as men in
plainclothes beat blindfolded and bound prisoners in the enclosed grounds of
the Iraqi Interior Ministry.



He immediately radioed for help. Soon after, a team of Oregon Army National
Guard soldiers swept into the yard and found dozens of Iraqi detainees who
said they had been beaten, starved and deprived of water for three days.

In a nearby building, the soldiers counted dozens more prisoners and what
appeared to be torture devices -- metal rods, rubber hoses, electrical wires
and bottles of chemicals. Many of the Iraqis, including one identified as a
14-year-old boy, had fresh welts and bruises across their back and legs.

The soldiers disarmed the Iraqi jailers, moved the prisoners into the shade,
released their handcuffs and administered first aid. Lt. Col. Daniel
Hendrickson of Albany, Ore., the highest ranking American at the scene,
radioed for instructions.

But in a move that frustrated and infuriated the guardsmen, Hendrickson's
superior officers told him to return the prisoners to their abusers and
immediately withdraw. It was June 29 -- Iraq's first official day as a
sovereign country since the U.S.-led invasion.

The incident, the first known case of human rights abuses in newly sovereign
Iraq, is at the heart of the American dilemma here.

In handing over power, U.S. officials gave Iraqis authority to run their own
institutions -- even if they made mistakes. But officials understand that
the United States will be held responsible when the new Iraqi authorities
stumble.

"Iraqis want us to respect their sovereignty, but the problem is we will be
blamed for leaving the fox in charge of the henhouse," said Michael Rubin, a
former adviser to the interim Iraqi government who is now a scholar at the
American Enterprise Institute. "We did not generally put good people in."

An Oregon guardsman who witnessed the day's events, Capt. Jarrell Southall,
provided The Oregonian with a written account of the incident. Other
guardsmen interviewed in Iraq corroborated Southall's account on the
condition that their names not be used.

The U.S. Embassy in Iraq confirmed the incident occurred and disclosed for
the first time that the United States raised questions about the June 29
"brutality" with Iraq's interior minister.

The embassy declined to say what response was received in the meeting
between the minister and James Jeffrey, the second-ranking U.S. diplomat in
Iraq, saying it would be "inappropriate" to discuss "details of those
diplomatic and confidential conversations."

The embassy, in a written statement, said U.S. soldiers are "compelled by
the law of land warfare and core values to stop willful and unnecessary use
of physical violence on prisoners." The U.S. soldiers involved in the
incident, it said, "acted professionally and calmly to ease tensions and
defend prisoners who needed help."

The June 29 confrontation between U.S. troops and Iraqi officials at the
Interior Ministry has been mentioned in news accounts in the United States
and Britain. But details about the prisoners' injuries, the actions of the
Oregon Guard and the high-level American decision to leave the injured
detainees in the hands of Iraqis has not been previously reported.

For their part, the Oregon guardsmen of the 2nd Battalion, 162nd Infantry
left the Interior Ministry confused over their roles in the murky job of
nation building. Hendrickson, a Corvallis police officer, refused to discuss
details of the incident but said:

"Oregonians should be proud of the actions taken by the 2/162 on June 29."

The Oregonians intervene

When U.S.-led forces drove Saddam Hussein from power in April 2003, the
Iraqi army was disbanded, and the country's social order collapsed. Looting
was common and petty crime skyrocketed. Local thugs settled scores and
exacted bribes with impunity. The rise in crime, coupled with the wave of
car bombings and kidnappings, undermined the legitimacy of the provisional
government.

In late June, on the eve of the transition of power, Iraq's prime minister
in waiting, Ayad Allawi, announced a crackdown on crime. Police and security
forces rounded up about 150 people in a seedy east Baghdad neighborhood.
Many Iraqis cheered the action, which netted a collection of immigrants and
poor Iraqis.

The Iraqi police took those arrested to a compound on the grounds of the
Interior Ministry.

On the morning of June 29, Oregon guardsmen set off from their base near the
Interior Ministry on routine neighborhood patrols.

Lookouts climbed towers ringing the base, and scouts took their usual
positions in hidden vantage points around the neighborhoods of east Baghdad,
looking for threats and signs of trouble.

One of the scouts posted in a tall building squinted through his rifle scope
at the courtyard adjoining the Interior Ministry. He saw a man in
plainclothes standing over a handcuffed and blindfolded prisoner. The
guardsman watched through his rifle scope as the man reared back and brought
what appeared to be a stick or metal rod down on the prisoner, who was lying
on the ground.

The scout took pictures through his scope and considered his options.

The Oregon guardsman did not speak for this story. But others who spoke with
the soldier said he radioed battalion headquarters to report the beating.
According to one soldier, he said he would begin shooting the Iraqi guards
if someone didn't intervene.

That message was passed to Lt. Col. Hendrickson, the battalion's commander,
who gathered soldiers from the unit's headquarters company and a translator.
Soon after, Hendrickson led a procession of Humvees from the guards' Patrol
Base Volunteer to the Iraqi compound.

The squad of armed and armored Oregon guardsmen pushed into the detention
yard "basically unchallenged," according to the written account by Southall,
a Newark, Calif., middle school teacher who serves with the Oregon Guard.

Southall said he was speaking as an individual and not as a military
officer. Senior Army officers have instructed soldiers not to discuss the
incident.

According to Southall and other soldiers, the guardsmen began by separating
the prisoners from the Iraqi policemen.

Some of the detainees said they had been held for three days with little
water and no food. "Many of these prisoners had bruises and cuts and belt or
hose marks all over," Southall said. At least one had a gunshot wound to the
knee.

"I witnessed prisoners who were barely able to walk," Southall said.

The Oregon soldiers moved the prisoners into the shade of a nearby wall, cut
them loose and handed out water bottles. They administered first aid when
necessary and gave intravenous fluids to at least one dehydrated prisoner.

At about that time, U.S. military police arrived on the scene and began
disarming the Iraqi policemen and moving them farther away from the
prisoners, according to Southall.

Hendrickson demanded through the interpreter to speak with someone in charge
of the Iraqi policemen. Two men came forward.

"One was a well-dressed obese man who told LTC Hendrickson that there was no
prisoner abuse and that everything was under control and they were trying to
conduct about 150 investigations as soon as possible," Southall said. The
other, smaller man, who Southall said identified himself as "Maj. Ahmed,"
claimed he was responsible for outside security only and that those
responsible for any prisoner abuse were inside the building.

Hendrickson then led some of the Oregon guardsmen inside to investigate
further.

"There were several rooms within the building," Southall said. "One room,
about 20 by 20 feet squared, contained even more prisoners, all in the same
sad shape as the prisoners found in the outer area. There were about 78
prisoners crowded in this little room with no available furniture, no air
conditioner, no water or food or restrooms available."

Southall said one prisoner claimed the Iraqi police arrested him at a market
and confiscated his passport even though he had "paid a tremendous bribe" to
the arresting officer. Others, many of whom appeared to be non-Arab
shopkeepers and workers, said they had been detained for lack of proper
identification.

The Oregon guardsmen walked into the adjoining office, where they saw
several Iraqis sitting around a table smoking cigarettes.

"There was a tightly bound and gagged prisoner crumpled at the feet of these
men," Southall said. "There was a recently eaten tray of food . . . and a
nice water cooler that was standing upright in good order. This room was
heavily air conditioned, which was a stark contrast to the rooms that
contained prisoners."

The men in the room said they had not beaten anyone. They asserted, however,
"that these prisoners were all dangerous criminals and most were thieves,
users of marijuana and other types of bad people," according to Southall's
account.

As U.S. soldiers continued to fan out in the building, they found more
bound-and-gagged prisoners, and "hoses, broken lamps and chemicals of some
variety," which could have been used as torture devices, Southall said.

Hendrickson radioed up the chain of command in the Army's 1st Cavalry
Division, relaying what he had seen and asking for instructions. As the
soldiers waited, Southall said, the Iraqi policemen began to get "defiant
and hostile" toward the Americans.

It wasn't long before the order came: Stand down. Return the prisoners to
the Iraqi authorities and leave the detention yard.

That order infuriated the Oregon guardsmen, who viewed themselves as
protectors of the abused prisoners. Nonetheless, the soldiers obeyed. None
of the soldiers interviewed for this story said which U.S. general gave the
order.

In the preceding weeks, the guardsmen had been bombarded with images of
Americans abusing Iraqi prisoners at the Abu Ghraib detention center. Those
images, which continue to reverberate through the Arab world, had been
replayed frequently on the televisions at Patrol Base Volunteer.

The guardsmen who later gave their account of that day said they wanted
Americans to know about the actions they took to protect unresisting
prisoners -- and that they were ordered by U.S. military officials to walk
away.

"The guys were really upset," said one soldier. Said another who talked to
them immediately afterward, "They were really moved by what they'd seen."

Hendrickson referred questions about the episode to Brig. Gen. Jeffrey
Hammond of the 1st Cavalry. The story of what happened June 29 "needs to be
told," Hammond acknowledged when interviewed by The Oregonian. But he said
that, "because of the nature of this issue, it's being handled at a higher
level than me."

What happened to the prisoners after the Americans departed is not clear.
Guardsmen interviewed for this story said they've watched the detention
facility closely since then, and that many of the prisoners were released
soon after the raid on the detention facility.

The soldiers said they have not seen any further prisoner abuse occur there.

On July 12, Iraqi Prime Minister Allawi ordered another sweep of poor,
crime-ridden east Baghdad neighborhoods. Afterward, Iraq said Allawi's
crackdown had netted more than 500 "killers, robbers, car thieves and
kidnappers."

U.S. officials say how Iraq handles the complaints about the roundups will
be a test of the country's fragile institutions. The new Iraqi constitution
bans "torture in all its forms, physical or mental," as well as "cruel,
inhuman, or degrading treatment."

The country now has a minister of human rights. Government ministries have
also assigned inspectors general to examine allegations of wrongdoing.

The U.S. Embassy's statement cast the United States as a supporting player
in building a government that is accountable. "The role of the United
States," it said, "is to assist the sovereign Iraqi government as it
continues on its path toward providing its citizens the opportunities and
protections available through a free and representative society."

But Robert Kagan, a senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for
International Peace in Washington, said the United States gave the Iraqis
sovereignty over a country that lacked functioning institutions and faced
daunting security problems.

"We didn't want to put in enough forces to defeat the insurgency," Kagan
said. "Now we hand it to the Iraqis, and we're surprised at how they do it?"

Stephen Engelberg of The Oregonian contributed to this report.

Mike Francis: 503-294-5955; mikefrancis at news.oregonian.com



http://www.oregonlive.com/search/index.ssf?/base/exclude/1092052712302080.xml?oregonian?ylccmf



Wyden asks why Guard told to leave abuse site
The Oregon senator wants the Defense Department to find out who ordered the
soldiers not to aid prisoners being beaten

Monday, August 09, 2004

MIKE FRANCIS

Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., demanded Sunday that Defense Secretary Donald
Rumsfeld investigate whether Oregon National Guardsmen were improperly
ordered by superior officers to leave a detention area where they intervened
to stop Iraqi guards from beating handcuffed prisoners.

On June 29, Iraq's first full day as a sovereign nation, a squad of Oregon
National Guardsmen in Baghdad raced to a detention yard near the Ministry of
the Interior to stop the abuse of Iraqi prisoners. The Oregon Guardsmen were
ordered by their superior officers to leave the detention facility and
return the prisoners to their jailers, soldiers said.



A Defense Department spokesman said Sunday the senator's request "will be
responded to as soon as the facts surrounding this incident can be
determined." The spokesman said that U.S. policy "condemns and prohibits
torture or abuse," and that "any reports of torture or abuse are
investigated thoroughly."

"We want to know who gave those orders" to stand down, said Wyden, a member
of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence. Wyden spoke by phone Sunday
from California, on his way to visit his mother. The intervention by Oregon
Guardsmen, followed by their forced withdrawal, portrays "a very serious
problem," he said.

Meanwhile, Oregon Gov. Ted Kulongoski issued a statement saying he is
"extremely proud" of the Oregon National Guard soldiers serving in Iraq.

"I am honored by their professionalism as soldiers, their conviction about
what is right and their basic sense of humanity," the governor said.

"I am very sorry that they had to witness these terrible events," Kulongoski
said. "While war sometimes brings out the best in us, it also brings out the
worst. I'm very grateful as an Oregonian that the soldiers of the Oregon
National Guard knew the difference. I would expect nothing less from these
courageous Oregonians who are serving our country."

The Oregonian's account of the episode, published in weekend editions,
described the actions taken by the soldiers on Iraq's first day of
sovereignty.

Account of events

The chain of events started when a National Guard scout witnessed Iraqi
guards beating bound and blindfolded prisoners on the grounds of Iraq's
Interior Ministry. The scout radioed his commanders at Patrol Base
Volunteer, and a squad of soldiers led by the battalion commander, Lt. Col.
Dan Hendrickson, raced to the detention area.

When they arrived, the soldiers began disarming the guards and giving aid to
the prisoners, whose backs, arms and legs were marked with welts and
bruises. They moved prisoners into the shade and distributed water bottles.

Inside a guardhouse in the compound, soldiers found more prisoners bound and
blindfolded and showing evidence of abuse. They also found rubber hoses,
chemicals and exposed electrical wires, which prisoners said had been used
in the "interrogations."

The Iraqi guards began arguing with the Americans, and Hendrickson radioed
his superior officers to ask for instructions. That's when higher-ups
ordered him to take his men and withdraw from the detention yard, leaving
the prisoners to their captors.

Order frustrated soldieers

The order to leave frustrated the soldiers, who thought they had done the
right thing to interrupt the beatings. Though they were instructed not to
discuss the incident, many described it to The Oregonian on the condition
that their names not be used.

One soldier, Capt. Jarrell Southall of Newark, Calif., provided a written
account and gave permission to use his name, though he stressed he spoke as
an individual, not as an Army officer.

Pete Cabrera of Portland served with Southall as a Marine recruiter in
1992-94. He said Sunday he wasn't surprised to learn that Southall defied
orders to keep quiet about the incident.

"He's an independent thinker," Cabrera said. "That's the kind of guy he is."

Capt. Mike Braibish, deputy chief of public affairs for the Oregon National
Guard in Salem, said Sunday, "We're proud of the Oregon soldiers serving in
Iraq, and we know we can count on them to do the right thing. In this case,
the soldiers did what they're trained to do: They responded to the situation
and reported the alleged abuse through their chain of command."

Braibish said the Oregon National Guard doesn't have details of the U.S. or
Iraqi response to the June 29 incident.

The U.S. Embassy in Iraq has confirmed the incident occurred and said last
week that the United States has asked Iraq's interior minister about the
June 29 "brutality."

Wyden said the investigation should "determine whether proper procedure and
law were followed by the American military commander(s) who allegedly gave
the order to return tortured prisoners to their torturers."

He also said he wants to ensure that soldiers who disclosed the incident to
The Oregonian aren't retaliated against.

"I'll be following up right away," he said.

Mike Francis: 503-294-5955; mikefrancis at news.oregonian.com