[Media-watch] Picture emerges of Falluja siege - BBC - 23/04/2004

[Julie-ann Davies]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3653223.stm

Picture emerges of Falluja siege

A truce has brought a reduction in violence in the Iraqi city of Falluja
after US troops fought insurgents there during a two-week siege.

There was little media access during the fighting, but eyewitness reports
are now emerging.

Humanitarian workers speak of US gunmen firing at ambulances and civilians.

They say makeshift clinics were overwhelmed because of a bridge closure
which cut off access to the main hospital.

US military officials have described the US operation as "humane" and say
they "do everything possible to protect non-combatants". But they say
insurgents' tactics are increasing the risks for civilians.

Coalition forces began the operation to "pacify" insurgent fighters in the
restive, mainly-Sunni city on 5 April. It followed the gruesome murder and
mutilation in late March of four security contractors working for the
coalition in the city.


Ambulance accusations:

The head of mission of a European humanitarian agency with staff in Falluja
told BBC News Online that, according to his staff, two of their ambulances
had been shot at.

"By who? The probability is by US snipers," he said.

Asked whether these were warning or attacking shots, he said: "One was shot
two or three times - a sniper does not shoot an ambulance three times by
mistake."

British aid worker Jo Wilding said an ambulance she was in, with flashing
lights, siren blaring and "ambulance" written on it in English, was hit as
it drove to collect a woman in premature labour.

Ms Wilding is sure the shots came from American troops.

"You can tell the shape of US marine from a mujahideen - even if you can
only see a silhouette, the helmet and flak jacket are quite distinctive.
Also, we were in a US-controlled part of town," she told BBC News Online.

Iraqi doctor Salam al-Obaidi, a member of the Doctors for Iraq humanitarian
society, worked in Falluja for six days during the fighting.

Speaking to BBC News Online, he described seeing colleagues blown up in an
ambulance - also clearly marked - travelling in front of him as his team
tried to enter a US-controlled area.

"I saw the ambulance disappear - not all of it, but the front of it, the
side where the driver and paramedic were," he said.

He said he and two more colleagues were injured in a second explosion. He
still does not know the fate of the two people in the first ambulance.

In a separate incident, Dr Obaidi said, a driver and paramedic in an
ambulance were shot in a US-controlled area - one in the chest, the other in
the eyes.

The injured civilians inside the ambulance bled to death during the next two
days as warning shots were fired when the team tried - four times - to
return to collect the ambulance, he said.


'Hidden weapons':

Three days into the siege, Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, the top commander of
U.S. forces in Iraq, denied that troops were firing on ambulances.

If this hospital was working it would have saved a lot of lives


Ibrahim Younis, Medecins Sans Frontieres"If we're shooting vehicles, it's
because those vehicles have shot at us," he said.

US officials have said that on one occasion, an insurgent gunman was seen
fleeing in an ambulance, and that weapons have been found in an aid convoy
west of the city.

Coalition military spokesman Brigadier General Mark Kimmit said that there
have been "a lot of people running around the city with blankets on their
vehicles asserting that they are ambulances".

There was concern that these could have been loaded with explosives, he
said.


Casualty figures:

The Iraqi death toll from the siege has been strongly contested. Local
doctors have been widely quoted as saying at least 600 people died.

Mr Obaidi believes the total to be at least 750, not including those buried
in gardens or other unofficial grave sites.

The Iraqi Health Minister, Khodair Abbas, said on Thursday that 271 people
died and local doctors had been pressured to give inflated figures.

The proportion of these who were civilians is impossible to verify.

Reports from the city have consistently said that many civilians in
US-controlled parts of the city were too afraid of US snipers to leave their
homes during the siege.

Dr Obaidi and Ms Wilding described cases of women, children and old men who
appeared to have been shot by US soldiers.

Dr Obaidi said he had seen the bodies of two men, one aged about 70, the
other about 50, both shot in the forehead, in an area controlled by the US.

They had been lying at the front gate of their home for two days, he said,
because the family did not dare step outside to retrieve the bodies.

Is he sure they were shot by US troops?

"You are joking?" he said. "There are people dead in an area just controlled
by America snipers. Nobody, either civilian or resistance, could enter the
area. Who could kill them? We know American bullets. We are not a stupid
people."

Ms Wilding said an injured mother and two children had told her they were
hit by US gunmen as they tried to leave their house.

She also said she met an old woman, shot in the abdomen, who was still
clutching a white flag.

"Her son said she had been shot by US soldiers," Ms Wilding said.

Dr Obaidi also said he had seen the body parts of a family in a bombed-out
house: "There were seven women and five children. I saw the head of a child
away from the body. Only one girl, aged four, had survived," he said.

US officials say their operations have been "extraordinarily precise".

Gen. Sanchez said civilian casualties were "absolutely regrettable", but
were a fact on a "battlefield of this nature in an urban environment".

Gen. Kimmit, also blamed militants who "hunker down inside mosques and
hospitals and schools, and use the women and children as shields" for the
civilian suffering.


Hospital access:

The US has also faced criticism for blocking access to the city's main
hospital by, according to most reports, occupying the river bridge which
linked it to the rest of the city.

"If this hospital was working it would have saved a lot of lives," Medecins
Sans Frontieres' Emergency Coordinator for Iraq Ibrahim Younis
said.

Doctors set up makeshift clinics in the early days of the siege.

Ms Wilding said doctors were storing blood in a drinks fridge at a GP's
surgery where they were treating the injured, and warming the bags under the
tap in an unhygienic toilet.

Dr Obaidi said hundreds of patients were brought in, but his team had only
10 beds.

Part of the deal to end the fighting was a US commitment to allow
"unfettered access" to the hospital and to "facilitate the passage of
official ambulances" in the city.

The Coalition says troops "have consistently allowed food, medical and
humanitarian supplies into the city" and have "assisted in the
transportation and distribution of these supplies".

It also says marines have helped ambulances from Baghdad to get into
Falluja, and that humanitarian convoys have been slowed by explosive devices
found on the roads.